top of page

Limitation of Liability Clauses in Ontario Supply Agreements: What Manufacturers Should Negotiate

3 days ago
5 min read

You supply $40,000 of machined brackets to an assembly customer. A dimensional defect stops the customer’s line for two days. The claim that follows includes shutdown costs, overtime, expedited freight, sorting labour and lost production, and it runs to many times the order value.


Machined metal component on engineering drawings for an Ontario supply agreement

Whether your exposure is $40,000 or several million dollars usually turns on one clause your sales team never priced: the limitation of liability. For an Ontario manufacturer or supplier, the time to negotiate that clause is before the agreement is signed, not after the first claim arrives.


In this article


1. Read the Limitation of Liability Clause as One Provision


Most limitation of liability clauses do two things. The exclusion removes whole categories of loss, typically indirect, consequential, special and punitive damages, and often lost profits. The cap limits the total amount recoverable for everything that remains, usually by reference to the order value, the fees paid in the prior twelve months, a fixed dollar figure or available insurance.


The two parts only work together. A generous cap paired with a narrow exclusion can leave you exposed to the full cost of a customer’s production losses. A tight cap paired with broad exceptions can mean the cap rarely applies at all. Review the clause as a single risk position and test it against the realistic worst case for the product you supply.


A liability cap is only as strong as the exclusions and exceptions written around it.

2. Define What Consequential Damages Means in Your Contract


The phrase “consequential damages” does not define itself. Courts read it in the context of the contract and the losses the parties could reasonably have anticipated when they signed. In manufacturing, the losses a customer cares most about, such as shutdown costs, recall expenses, rework, replacement parts and expedited freight, may be treated as direct losses. If they are direct, a general exclusion of consequential damages will not remove them.


The practical answer is to name the losses. If your pricing assumes you will not absorb a customer’s lost production, downtime or recall costs, the clause should say so expressly. If the customer insists on recovering some of them, agree on which ones and at what limit. Customer charges deserve the same scrutiny, including downstream chargebacks and liquidated damages for late delivery.


3. Negotiate the Exceptions to the Cap Deliberately


Most customers ask for certain liabilities to sit outside the cap. Common examples include breach of confidentiality, intellectual property infringement, bodily injury and property damage, and wilful misconduct or gross negligence. Each request is reasonable on its own. Together, they can remove most of the protection the cap was meant to provide.


Indemnities need particular attention. A broad indemnity for “any and all claims arising from the products” that sits outside the cap can expose you to unlimited liability for the customer’s own downstream claims. Before agreeing to an exception, confirm whether your insurance responds to it. Your broker can tell you whether your product liability, recall and errors and omissions coverage lines up with what the contract asks you to carry.


Reviewing a supply agreement liability clause? Book a consultation and we will tell you which caps, exclusions and indemnities to accept, negotiate or escalate before you sign.


4. Check How the Clause Works With Your Warranty


Ontario’s Sale of Goods Act implies conditions into many sales, including that goods bought by description from a seller who deals in them will be of merchantable quality, and that goods will be reasonably fit for a purpose the buyer made known when relying on the seller’s skill or judgment. Section 53 of the Act allows implied rights and liabilities to be negatived or varied by express agreement.


The warranty decides what you promise. The limitation clause decides what a broken promise costs.

That is why the warranty and the limitation clause should be drafted together. A well structured supply agreement states the express warranty, the warranty period and the remedy, often repair, replacement or credit, and makes that remedy the customer’s exclusive remedy for defects. Customer forms often do the opposite. If the customer’s purchase order terms conflict with your quote, resolve the battle of the forms before production starts.


5. Confirm the Clause Will Hold Up


Canadian courts generally give effect to clearly drafted limitation clauses between commercial parties. The Supreme Court of Canada set the framework in Tercon Contractors Ltd. v. British Columbia, 2010 SCC 4. The court asks whether the clause applies to the circumstances as a matter of interpretation, whether it was unconscionable when the contract was made, and whether an overriding public policy reason should prevent its enforcement.


Most disputes are decided at the first step. Ambiguous wording, inconsistent terms across a master agreement, statement of work and purchase order, or a clause that does not clearly reach the type of claim being made will all weaken your position. If the same liability debates come up with every major customer, it may be time to modernize your contracts or put ongoing legal support behind your sales and procurement teams.


Frequently Asked Questions


It is a clause that restricts the amount and types of loss one party can recover from the other. It usually combines a monetary cap with an exclusion of certain categories of damages, such as indirect or consequential losses and lost profits.

Generally, yes, between commercial parties. Courts apply the Supreme Court of Canada’s test in Tercon, which looks at whether the clause applies on its wording, whether it was unconscionable when made, and whether public policy should override it.

Not necessarily. Depending on the contract and the circumstances, shutdown, recall and rework costs may be treated as direct losses. If you do not intend to cover them, the clause should exclude them by name.

Common reference points include the value of the order, fees paid over the prior twelve months, a fixed amount or available insurance limits. The right choice depends on your margin, the customer’s realistic exposure and what your insurance will respond to.

That is a negotiation point. Third party bodily injury and intellectual property claims often sit outside the cap, while broad product indemnities should usually be capped or narrowed so they do not cancel the protection the cap provides.



Learn More


To see how we support component and raw material suppliers, visit our Legal Services for Components & Raw Materials page, or explore our Legal Services for Manufacturers & Distributors.


Is your liability exposure priced into the deal?


Caps, exclusions, indemnities and warranties should match what you charge and what you insure. Delta Law helps Ontario manufacturers and suppliers negotiate liability terms before the agreement is signed.



This article provides general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create a lawyer-client relationship.

bottom of page