Governing Law and Jurisdiction Clauses: What to Check When a U.S. Customer’s Contract Picks Its Home State
A new U.S. customer sends its standard supply agreement. Buried near the end is a clause stating that the agreement is governed by the law of its home state and that any dispute must be brought in that state’s courts. Your team signs because the commercial terms look fine.

That clause decides which rules will be used to read every other term in the contract and where you would have to go to enforce them. For an Ontario manufacturer selling into the United States, it deserves the same attention as price and payment terms.
In this article
1. Separate the Governing Law Clause From the Jurisdiction Clause
These are two different clauses that often sit in the same paragraph. The governing law clause decides which legal system is used to interpret the contract and fill its gaps. The jurisdiction or forum clause decides where disputes will be resolved, such as the courts of a particular state or province, or arbitration.
Each can be negotiated separately. A customer may accept Ontario law but insist on its own courts, or the reverse. Treat them as two decisions, and make sure the wording says whether the chosen courts are exclusive or simply one available option.
2. Know What the Customer’s Choice of Law Changes
U.S. state law reads sales contracts differently from Ontario law in ways that matter to manufacturers, including implied warranties, how conflicting forms are resolved and how limitation clauses are applied. Your standard terms were likely written with Ontario law in mind, so a change of governing law can change what those terms mean.
Sales between businesses in Canada and the United States are also generally governed by the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods unless the contract excludes it. Many customer forms exclude it. Whether you want it to apply is a decision to make deliberately, not a default to accept.
The governing law clause decides how every other clause in the contract will be read.
3. Expect a Clear Forum Clause to Be Enforced
Canadian courts generally hold commercial parties to the forum they agreed to. In Z.I. Pompey Industrie v. ECU-Line N.V., 2003 SCC 27, the Supreme Court of Canada held that a party seeking to avoid a valid forum selection clause must show strong cause why it should not be enforced, and the Court reaffirmed that framework in Douez v. Facebook, Inc., 2017 SCC 33.
In practice, if you agree to a U.S. customer’s home courts, you should assume that is where any dispute will be heard. That affects the cost of collecting unpaid invoices, enforcing a liability cap or defending a warranty claim, so the decision should be priced into the deal.
Reviewing a U.S. customer’s contract? Book a consultation and we will tell you which governing law and jurisdiction terms to accept, negotiate or escalate before you sign.
4. Consider Neutral Options, Including Arbitration
If neither side will accept the other’s home law and courts, there are workable middle grounds. Parties sometimes choose a neutral governing law, split the forum so each party sues in the other’s home courts, or agree to arbitration under recognized institutional rules with a seat both can accept.
Arbitration is often attractive in cross border supply relationships because Canada and the United States are both parties to the New York Convention on the recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards. The clause still needs care: choose the rules, the seat, the number of arbitrators and the language, and confirm the cost suits the size of the contracts involved.
5. Align the Clause With the Rest of the Deal
Governing law and forum terms should be consistent across the master agreement, statements of work, customer purchase orders and your own sales terms. If they conflict, you may face a battle of the forms over which clause applies.
Review them alongside your delivery and price terms as well. Our article on Incoterms, duties and tariff risk covers the commercial side of selling to U.S. customers, and our limitation of liability article covers the risk terms the governing law will shape. If you sell through partners, settle these points once in your distribution agreement.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between governing law and jurisdiction?
Governing law decides which legal system is used to interpret the contract. Jurisdiction, or forum, decides where disputes will be resolved. They are separate clauses and can be negotiated separately.
Will an Ontario court enforce a clause choosing U.S. courts?
Generally, yes, if the clause is valid and clear. Under the Supreme Court of Canada’s decision in Z.I. Pompey, the party resisting the clause must show strong cause why it should not be enforced.
Does the CISG apply to our sales to U.S. customers?
Sales between businesses in Canada and the United States are generally governed by the CISG unless the contract excludes it. Many customer forms do exclude it, so check the wording.
Is arbitration a good alternative to a customer’s home courts?
It can be, particularly because Canada and the United States are both parties to the New York Convention. The rules, seat, number of arbitrators and cost should all suit the contracts involved.
Can we accept a U.S. customer’s governing law and keep our standard terms?
You can, but your terms may be read differently under U.S. state law. Review warranty, limitation and payment terms against the chosen law before you agree.
Learn More
To see how we support cross border sellers, visit our Legal Services for Importers & Exporters page, or explore our Legal Services for Manufacturers & Distributors.
Is a U.S. customer choosing the rules for your contract?
Governing law and jurisdiction clauses decide how your contract is read and where it is enforced. Delta Law helps Ontario manufacturers review and negotiate these terms before the agreement is signed.
This article provides general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create a lawyer-client relationship.



