top of page

Common Legal Mistakes Medical Clinics Make

Sep 12, 2024
4 min read

Updated: 4 hours ago

Most legal problems in Ontario medical clinics start the same way: a structure that grew informally, agreements copied from another clinic and records arrangements nobody wrote down. They surface when a physician leaves, a patient asks for a record or the College opens a file.


Black and white stethoscope resting on a sheet, illustrating common legal mistakes medical clinics make in Ontario

This guide explains the common legal mistakes medical clinics make in Ontario and how to fix each one, from physician agreements and classification to records, fees, staff and exits.


In this article


Common Legal Mistakes Medical Clinics Make With Agreements


The first mistake is running on handshakes or a template from another clinic. Each physician should have a signed agreement that matches how they actually practise: services, schedule, overhead, billing, records, insurance, non-solicitation and exit. Agreements should also be consistent with each other. When two physicians have different overhead formulas for the same services and no one can explain why, a dispute is a matter of time.


Misclassifying Physicians


Calling a physician an independent contractor does not make them one. If the clinic sets hours, approves vacation, bars outside work and pays a fixed amount regardless of billings, the relationship may be employment. That brings termination notice, severance and payroll deduction exposure, and would void most non-compete clauses. Our guide to contractor vs employee status in medical clinics covers the test.


A clinic agreement is only as strong as its records clause and its exit clause. Those are where disputes start.

Leaving Records Custody Unwritten


The College requires physicians to have a written agreement that establishes custodianship and clear accountabilities for medical records, where applicable, as set out in its Practice Management obligations. Without one, a clinic and a departing physician can end up disputing who controls the chart. The agreement should name the health information custodian, set access rights after departure and confirm that records are kept for at least 10 years after the last entry, or 10 years after a child turns 18.


Vague Overhead and Revenue Terms


Overhead disputes usually come from undefined terms. State whether the percentage applies to billings or collections, which revenue streams it covers, what happens to rejected or recovered claims, when the clinic remits payment and what reporting each physician receives. List the services the overhead buys, such as space, staff, EMR and supplies, and say which costs fall outside it.


Charging Uninsured Fees Without Clear Notice


The College requires fees for uninsured services, such as forms and missed appointment fees, to be reasonable, and requires patients or third parties to be told about a fee before the service is provided, unless that is impossible or impractical. Clinics often post a fee schedule but never decide who sets fees, who collects them and how they are shared. Put those answers in the physician agreements.


Question? Book a consultation and we will review your clinic agreements and flag the gaps before they become disputes.


Forgetting That Staff Rules Differ


Employed physicians are exempt from the Employment Standards Act's hours, overtime, minimum wage, public holiday and vacation rules under Ontario Regulation 285/01. Nurses, medical office assistants and other staff are not. Clinics that apply physician-style terms to staff risk unpaid overtime and vacation pay claims. Non-compete clauses with any employee have been prohibited since October 25, 2021, with narrow exceptions.


Blurring the Clinic and the Professional Corporations


Physicians often practise through their own medicine professional corporations while a separate company runs the clinic. Problems arise when the wrong entity signs the lease, staff contracts or physician agreements, or when funds move between entities without documentation. Each corporation should have its own bank account, its own contracts and a written agreement setting out what the clinic provides and what it charges.


No Plan for Departures


The College treats a physician relocating to a new practice location as a practice closure, and requires patients to be notified as early as possible and at least three months before. Agreements often say nothing about who sends that notice, what it says, how records are accessed afterwards or how final billings are reconciled. Settle those points at signing, when both sides still want the relationship to work.


Frequently Asked Questions


Running without signed physician agreements that match how each physician actually practises, or relying on a template copied from another clinic.

The College requires a written agreement establishing custodianship and accountabilities for medical records where applicable, and it calls such agreements essential in group practices.

Yes, for appointments missed or cancelled less than 24 hours ahead, if the fee is reasonable and patients are told about it in advance.

No. The exemption covers employees practising medicine, not nurses, medical office assistants or other staff.

The College requires notice as early as possible and at least three months before a planned closure, which includes relocating to a new practice.



Learn More


To see how we support physicians, visit our Legal Services for Physicians page, or explore our work with Healthcare and Wellness practices.


Running a medical clinic?


Agreements, records custody, fees and exit terms are where clinic disputes start. Delta Law reviews and drafts clinic documents for Ontario physicians.



This article provides general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create a lawyer-client relationship.

 
 
bottom of page